# Sec. 1301. Definitions

BAAJA draft released September 30, 2026. AI-assisted analysis; proposed changes.

Saved AI review: 794 supported, 0 flagged, 18 unchecked of 812 statements; checked 2026-10-06; stale: true. Coverage excludes current-law comparison cells and some research paraphrases. Read data/core.json checks for link and quote results and their dates. A stale review does not verify the current wording.

[Official PDF](https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/5/c/5c5f5935-b224-48e7-abea-e60c30e7a4cf/7935BF3C85967B6F56F6F4858FD3221B7E0AEB02D04BE391CAFBD1B884CE3DC5.bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-text.pdf) · [Browser section](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/#/bill/sec/1301)

## Summary

Defines 'best scientific and commercial data available' in the Endangered Species Act as all relevant, objective information at the time of the action, including models that account for error and are applied without policy presumptions. ([p. 133, line 20 to p. 133, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133))

## Key points

- Defines 'best scientific and commercial data available' in the statute ([p. 133, line 20 to p. 133, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133))

## What others say it would do

Outside readings, quoted from their sources. These are claims about effects, not findings of this tracker.

- **pv magazine USA** (Reporting; concerns): As SELC reads it, the ESA Section 7 changes would exclude relevant data from species reviews and lock in agency decisions.
  > revisions to Endangered Species Act Section 7 consultation rules would exclude relevant data from species reviews, increasing harm to threatened wildlife while locking in administrative decisions to prevent future regulatory reversal.
  [pv magazine USA, 2026-10-01](http://pv-magazine-usa.com/2026/10/01/senate-introduces-landmark-permitting-bill-as-industry-data-and-environmental-groups-clash-over-reforms/). On the bill text at [p. 133, line 20 to p. 133, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133).
- **Rep. Jared Huffman** (Officials; opposes): The Senate bill's ESA provisions give away too much and Democrats should wait for a stronger position after the election.
  > He claimed the Senate version “concedes too much,” specifically regarding the Endangered Species Act.
  [Washington Examiner, 2026-10-01](https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/daily-on-energy/4750722/daily-on-energy-a-baaja-blast-for-data-centers/).
- **The Hill** (Reporting; concerns): The new 'best available science' definition sets too high a threshold and could keep some threatened species from being listed.
  > saying the proposed definition creates too high a threshold and could prevent truly threatened creatures from being protected.
  [The Hill, 2026-10-01](https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/6124792-bipartisan-permitting-reform-data-centers-energy-projects/). On the bill text at [p. 133, line 20 to p. 133, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133).
- **Eno Center for Transportation** (Think tanks; concerns): The 'impartial data' definition for ESA science could be used to discard species data gathered by advocacy organizations.
  > could be used to disqualify sources of species data gathered by organizations with stated policy interests.
  [Eno Center for Transportation, 2026-10-02](https://enotrans.org/article/senate-proposes-major-changes-to-permit-and-review-processes/). On the bill text at [p. 134, line 6 to p. 134, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134).
- **Rep. Jared Huffman** (Officials; opposes): The ESA delegation to states and new definitions are so extreme that a milder version cost Westerman's ESA bill House Republican support.
  > Hollowing out the Endangered Species Act through the delegation of authority and problematic definitions, for example, is so extreme that a milder version of it spooked several House Republicans off of Bruce Westerman's ESA bill earlier this year
  [House Natural Resources Democrats, 2026-09-30](https://huffman.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/ranking-member-huffman-statement-on-senate-permitting-deal). On the bill text at [p. 137, line 24 to p. 138, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=137).
- **Center for Biological Diversity and 214 other groups** (Environmental groups; opposes): The definition would make the Services wait for firmer evidence before protecting a species, because it limits how they can weigh uncertainty and foreseeable risk.
  > would significantly raise the evidentiary burden for protecting imperiled animals and plants by limiting the Services’ ability to account for uncertainty and reasonably foreseeable risks
  [Coalition letter (Center for Biological Diversity), 2026-10-06](https://biologicaldiversity.org/programs/government-affairs/pdfs/Oppose-ESA-attacks-in-permitting-deal.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 134, line 6 to p. 134, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): The definition stops the Services from defaulting to worst-case assumptions, partly writing the D.C. Circuit's Maine Lobstermen decision into law.
  > Under the new language, the Services could no longer default to using the worst-case scenarios when making a jeopardy or critical habitat determination
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-09-30](https://ifp.org/how-the-permitting-deal-works/). On the bill text at [p. 134, line 6 to p. 134, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134).

## Selected statutory quotes

> are impartially gathered and objectively applied without presumptions or policy prescriptions that bias the application.

[p. 134, line 6 to p. 134, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134)

Part of the new definition of best available data.

## Comparison notes

- [SPEED Act (H.R. 4776), engrossed in House](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm)
- [Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024 (S. 4753), reported in Senate](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm)

### Current law

The ESA uses the phrase without defining it.

### EPRA 2024 (reported S. 4753)

Not in EPRA 2024.

### SPEED Act (House-passed H.R. 4776)

Not in the SPEED Act.

## Full statutory text

Extracted from the official PDF; line cites mark paragraph starts. Consult the PDF for exact layout.

[p. 133, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133) (indent level 0)

Section 3 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1532) is amended—

[p. 133, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133) (indent level 2)

(1) by redesignating paragraphs (2) through (10) as paragraphs (3) through (11), respectively;

[p. 133, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133) (indent level 2)

(2) by inserting after paragraph (1) the following:

[p. 133, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133) (indent level 2)

“(2) The terms ‘best scientific and commercial data available’ and ‘best scientific data available’—

[p. 133, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133) (indent level 3)

“(A) mean all relevant and objective scientific and commercial information available at the time of the agency action; and

[p. 133, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=133) (indent level 3)

“(B) include credible and reliable data, quantitative analyses, conceptual and numerical models, and model results that—

[p. 134, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134) (indent level 4)

“(i) account for known or potential sources of error;

[p. 134, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134) (indent level 4)

“(ii) are applied using prevailing principles, methods, tools, and professional standards of practice; and

[p. 134, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134) (indent level 4)

“(iii) are impartially gathered and objectively applied without presumptions or policy prescriptions that bias the application.”; and

[p. 134, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=134) (indent level 2)

(3) in paragraph (17), by striking “the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands” and inserting “the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands”.

