Amendments to the permitting bill

What the November 7 substitute changes in each section of the September 30 text, with page and line cites in both PDFs, other amendments filed or announced, and who has said they support or oppose them.

Updated 2026-11-18 · Open interactive view

Jump to: Key changes · All changes · Reactions · Other amendments · Filed amendments

Key changes

The November 7 substitute

The four sponsors' revised text of BAAJA, offered as a substitute for H.R. 2347, the House bill the Senate is using to carry it. Substitute PDF · Sponsors' release · Sponsors' staff summary of changes

417 pages and 71 sections on September 30; 494 pages and 83 sections on November 7. 43 sections edited, 13 added, 1 dropped, 2 renumbered, 25 unchanged.

Division A, Title I: National Environmental Policy Act Of 1969

Sec. 1102. Definitions · Edited

Sec. 1103. Implementing procedures · Edited

Sec. 1106. Timely and unified Federal reviews · Edited

Sec. 1109. Applications for authorizations · Edited

Sec. 1110. Judicial review · Edited

Sec. 1121. Council on Environmental Quality · Edited

Sec. 1131. Definitions · Edited

Sec. 1132. Environmental Review and Permitting Tracker · Edited

Sec. 1134. Limitation on claims for FAST-41 covered projects · New

Division A, Title Ii: Clean Water Act

Sec. 1202. Clean Water Act permitting and State certification · Edited

Sec. 1204. Permits for dredged or fill material · Edited

Sec. 1205. Judicial review timeline clarity · Edited

Division A, Title Iii: Endangered Species Act Of 1973

Sec. 1304. State assumption of consultation responsibilities · Edited

Sec. 1305. Judicial review · Edited

Sec. 1308. National Fish and Wildlife Foundation Coastal State Fund · Edited

Sec. 1309. State wildlife action plans · New

Division A, Title Iv: Project Certainty

Sec. 1401. Maintaining Federal authorizations or permits for projects with non-Federal sponsors · Edited

Sec. 1402. Ensuring fairness for specific types of covered projects · Edited

Sec. 1403. Avoiding unreasonable delays in permitting · Edited

Division A, Title V: Nuclear Energy Licensing

Sec. 1501. Updating Hearing Procedures · New

Sec. 1502. Licensing of uranium enrichment facilities · New

Sec. 1503. Applicability of deadlines to certain nuclear facilities · New

Sec. 1504. Compensation authority for career appointees · New

Division A, Title Vi: Other Environmental Matters

Sec. 1601. Wildfire emissions prevention · New

Sec. 1602. Brownfields revitalization · New

Division B, Title I: Electric Transmission

Sec. 2101. Transmission permitting · Edited

Sec. 2102. Reconductoring and other activities in existing rights-of-way · Edited

Sec. 2103. Transmission planning · Edited

Sec. 2104. Improvements relating to local transmission planning and development · Edited

Sec. 2105. Prohibition of right of first refusal · Edited

Sec. 2106. Consolidated planning process · Edited

Sec. 2107. Ratepayer protection · Edited

Sec. 2108. Dispatchable energy systems market access · Edited

Sec. 2109. Grid-enhancing advanced transmission technologies · Edited (September 30: Sec. 2109. Advanced transmission technologies)

Sec. 2110. Expediting generator interconnection queues · Edited

Sec. 2111. Grid data access · Edited

Sec. 2112. Power marketing administrations · Edited

Sec. 2113. FERC fee assessments · Edited

Sec. 2114. Collection of data on computational load entities · Edited

Sec. 2115. De novo review of civil penalties under the Natural Gas Act · New

Sec. 2116. Transmission Organization governance · New

Sec. 2117. Data Center Community Assistance Program · New

Sec. 2118. Conforming amendments; savings provision · Renumbered (September 30: Sec. 2115. Conforming amendments; savings provision)

Division B, Title Ii: Energy Permitting

Sec. 2201. Accelerating claims · Edited

Sec. 2212. Modification of Tribal leases and rights-of-way across Indian land · Edited (September 30: Sec. 2212. Rights-of-way across Indian land)

Sec. 2215. Hardrock mining mill sites · Edited

Sec. 2221. Geothermal observation test projects · Edited

Sec. 2222. Geothermal royalties · Edited

Sec. 2224. Geothermal Ombudsman and Permitting Task Force · Edited (September 30: Sec. 2224. Geothermal ombudsman and permitting task force)

Sec. 2225. No Federal permit required for geothermal activities on certain land · Edited

Sec. 2229. NEPA review · Edited (September 30: Sec. 2229. NEPA Review)

Sec. 2234. Micro hydrokinetic energy projects · Edited

Sec. 2242. Northwest Power and Conservation Council · Dropped

Sec. 2242. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission personnel safety · Renumbered (September 30: Sec. 2243. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission personnel safety)

Sec. 2252. Offshore energy transmission · Edited

Sec. 2261. Public announcement requirements for Department of Energy actions relating to certain nuclear facilities · New

Division B, Title Iii: Historic Preservation

Sec. 2301. Historic preservation · Edited

Sec. 2302. Funding for the Historic Preservation Fund; grants for Tribal Historic Preservation officers; additional funding · Edited (September 30: Sec. 2302. Funding for the Historic Preservation Fund; use and availability; grants for Tribal Historic Preservation officers; additional funding)

Division C: Survivor Justice Tax Prevention Act

Sec. 3001. Exclusion from gross income of any damages, other than punitive damages, received on account of sexual acts or sexual contact · New

Unchanged (25): Sec. 1101, Sec. 1104, Sec. 1105, Sec. 1107, Sec. 1108, Sec. 1133, Sec. 1201, Sec. 1203, Sec. 1301, Sec. 1302, Sec. 1303, Sec. 1306, Sec. 1307, Sec. 2211, Sec. 2213, Sec. 2214, Sec. 2223, Sec. 2226, Sec. 2227, Sec. 2228, Sec. 2231, Sec. 2232, Sec. 2233, Sec. 2241, Sec. 2251

Other amendments

SA 6883 · Thune for Capito

The sponsors' November 7 substitute, submitted on November 10 as a full replacement for the text of H.R. 2347. Thune filed to end debate on it on November 11, and the Senate voted 70 to 27 on November 16 to end debate on it (roll call 264). Status: pending, 2026-11-10.

“Capito substitute amendment #6883 to H.R.2347, Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026.” U.S. Senate Press Gallery

“Submitted and Proposed 11/10/2026” Congress.gov

SA 6884 to SA 6890 · Thune

Seven amendments the majority leader proposed after the substitute, with a motion to commit the bill to the Finance Committee. Their text was not read; congress.gov refused the request. Status: pending, 2026-11-10.

“Thune to commit to Senate Committee on Finance with instructions to report back forthwith with the following amendment (SA 6888) made in Senate.” Senate floor activity, November 10

172 filed amendments · filed by senators

The Congressional Record prints 172 amendments filed from November 10 to 17: 128 to the substitute and 44 to H.R. 2347. Congress.gov listed 113 to the substitute on November 16; its pages refused this site's request, so the two counts were not reconciled. The full list is below. Status: filed, 2026-11-17.

“submitted an amendment intended to be proposed to amendment SA 6883” Congressional Record, November 17

“Amendments to This Amendment (113)” Congress.gov, November 16

SA 7022 · Lee, for the four sponsors

The sponsors' managers' amendment. Besides technical corrections it makes federal permits public, adds landowner notice, land restoration and conduct rules for transmission permits, says when federal funding brings a project under historic preservation review, and raises the Historic Preservation Fund from $200 million to $300 million a year. Capito said it answers concerns about Tribal sovereignty and landowners along transmission lines. Status: submitted, 2026-11-17.

“Any action that is a Federal authorization or permit shall be made public” Congressional Record, November 17

“Tribal sovereignty and landowner rights related to transmission lines crossing farmland and private property” Nico Portuondo, POLITICO (X)

“I obtained the new managers' amendment text.” Joshua Siegel, Punchbowl News (X)

SA 6882 · Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.)

Strikes the historic preservation title (division B, title III). Heatmap reported nearly 30 Democrats back it. A Schiff spokesman said he wants a floor vote before final passage; Whitehouse said the four sponsors will vote against standalone amendments that get floor votes. Status: filed, 2026-11-10.

“Strike title III of division B.” Congressional Record, November 10

“nearly 30 Democrats have signed onto an amendment proposed by California Senator Adam Schiff” Heatmap

“The amendment is strictly germane…and has the support of two-thirds of the Democratic Caucus” Joshua Siegel, Punchbowl News (X)

“That’s pretty standard on bipartisan bills that the sponsors stand by the bill.” Joshua Siegel, Punchbowl News (X)

Budget point of order · Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.)

Under the Senate's order of November 17, if Merkley raises a budget point of order against the substitute, the Senate votes on a motion to waive it at 11:45 a.m. on November 18, before voting on adopting the substitute. The sources read do not say which budget rule it cites. Status: pending, 2026-11-18.

“if Senator Merkley or his designee raises a point of order on substitute amendment No. 6883, the Senate vote in relation to the point of order at 11:45 a.m.” Congressional Record, November 17

“Motion to waive the Merkley Budget Point of Order in relation to Capito substitute amendment #6883 (if raised)” U.S. Senate Press Gallery

Filed amendments (172)

Every amendment the Congressional Record prints as filed to the substitute (SA 6883) or to H.R. 2347, with its opening words. Descriptions of what an amendment does are AI-written from its text; amendments without one change page-and-line text of the substitute. Source: Congressional Record, Senate, Text of Amendments, 2026-11-10 to 2026-11-17.

Reactions to the substitute

Statements on the November 7 substitute. Positions on the bill as introduced are on the Key issues page.

Support

Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), Sponsor; chair, Environment and Public Works, 2026-11-07: “I urge the swift passage of BAAJA to make life more affordable for American families” Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee

Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), Sponsor; chair, Energy and Natural Resources, 2026-11-07: “It’s time to finish what we started” Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee

Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), Sponsor; ranking member, Energy and Natural Resources, 2026-11-07: “Americans can’t afford to wait for lower electricity prices. We need to pass this bill now” Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), Sponsor; ranking member, Environment and Public Works, 2026-11-07: “Our manager’s amendment improves BAAJA and addresses the thoughtful feedback we have received” Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee

Oppose

Mark Macarro, President, National Congress of American Indians, 2026-11-07: “Any amendments to S. 5653 merely puts lipstick on a pig.” Native News Online

106 Coalition, Tribal organizations, including NCAI; as reported by Heatmap, 2026-11-07: “sent a statement to media saying they’ll still oppose the bill and want the entire section of NHPA changes removed” Heatmap News

11 tribal organizations, including NCAI, NARF and NATHPO, Joint statement; as reported by Tribal Business News, 2026-11-08: “urged Congress to hold the bill until the next Congress can conduct meaningful tribal consultation” Tribal Business News

American Cultural Resources Association, Trade association for cultural resource firms, 2026-11-08: “even the managers' amendment would end Section 106 as we know it” American Cultural Resources Association

Erich Pica, President, Friends of the Earth U.S., 2026-11-07: “This isn’t a permitting compromise, it’s a sellout.” Friends of the Earth

Tracy Stone-Manning, President, The Wilderness Society, 2026-11-07: “Americans deserve permitting reform that isn’t crafted behind closed doors and rushed to the Senate floor” Heatmap News

Elizabeth Bast, Executive director, Oil Change International, 2026-11-08: “No amount of last-minute tinkering can disguise that this bill is a massive giveaway to fossil fuel companies and Big Tech” Common Dreams

Mixed

Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.), Ranking member, House Natural Resources, 2026-11-07: “we could improve it further in this and other areas with a hearing and a more open negotiation process with more Democrats in the room” Heatmap News

Coalition of Large Tribes, Tribal coalition, 2026-11-07: “grateful to see many positive changes for tribes” Heatmap News

Undecided

Eric Biber, Law professor, UC Berkeley; writes for Legal Planet, 2026-11-08: “still undecided about the bill, in part because I keep discovering major issues in the text” Legal Planet

Comment on a section

David Pomerantz, Executive director, Energy and Policy Institute, 2026-11-07: “I am relieved that the section survived generally, given what a target this was for utility lobbying.” Heatmap News

Rob Gramlich, President, Grid Strategies, 2026-11-07: “they provide more flexibility for more types of projects to go through” Heatmap News

National Association of Counties, County governments, 2026-11-09: “The ANS maintains core county wins in the legislation, including codifying counties as cooperating agencies during NEPA reviews” National Association of Counties